A proposal to construct over 200 residences in a Solihull settlement has received approval despite opponents continuously raising worries about potential harm to a historic windmill that is two centuries old. As previously reported, Solihull Council’s planning panel gave outline consent for 250 dwellings on land at Pheasant Oak Farm, situated on Waste Lane in Balsall Common.

The Vistry Homes scheme additionally features a playground for children, a shared orchard and wildlife zones. Exactly half of the homes proposed for the location will be affordable properties.

A detailed reserved matters submission addressing aspects such as design, dimensions, aesthetics and planting was filed earlier in the year and reviewed during the most recent committee session. When members of the public were invited to speak, Jeanette McGarry, who operates Berkswell Windmill, stated that the committee was aware of backing from their constituency MP Saqib Bhatti alongside local councillors.

She emphasized that the surroundings of Berkswell Windmill warranted preservation as they were clearly significant. She clarified they were not opposed to residential development entirely, but maintained that properties on the corner of Windmill Lane would negatively impact the windmill.

Councillor Tony Dicicco supported the calls to safeguard the windmill, characterising it as a notable landmark with relevance at local, national and international levels. He advocated for public green space directly opposite the structure, noting this location offered the ideal vantage point.

A representative from Vistry Homes explained that the company had implemented various changes to the scheme following consultations with the parish council, ward members and local inhabitants. He asserted the development fulfilled community requirements and expectations, while pointing out that council planning officers had recommended approval of the latest submission.

As the committee discussion began, Chair Councillor Bob Grinsell noted the applicant’s response to his calls for public open space.

Lawrence Osbourne, the council’s area planning officer, observed that some adjustments had been made, with an increase in the amount of public open space provided.

Councillor James Bradley commented that height parameters had been established during the outline planning approval. He questioned whether, given the application’s adherence to these parameters, any additional consideration could be given to the windmill.

Mr Osbourne replied that they had undertaken all feasible measures.

Upon the chair requesting a vote, the committee voted in favour without opposition to approve the application, subject to specified conditions.

The session was held at the Civic Suite on 24 July.